​​📜 Calamus vs Cannabis: Reexamining Biblical Botany​

​​

Security Warnings: 1. https://poe.com/s/VTP6W13vJQOoozyHo8E8

2. https://www.perplexity.ai/search/create-post-bfreedindeed-net-m-mFJLiiDKSQG3Une8w8wvnA

​

To preserve this information, we strongly recommend copying & pasting any section or text for personal study into an independent AI tools such as Chat GPT for cross-referencing | Ask Anything, Get True Answers

​

“Buy the truth, and sell it not; also wisdom, and instruction, and understanding.” — Proverbs 23:23

​​​​

The Controversy Over the "Reed" in Scripture
 

For centuries, debate has surrounded the identity of the plant referred to as the “reed” (Hebrew: kaneh or kaneh-bosm) in the Hebrew Bible — particularly in the accounts of Jesus’ crucifixion and the recipe for the sacred anointing oil.

While traditional interpretations favor calamus (Acorus calamus), modern linguistic, botanical, and archaeological scholarship increasingly points to cannabis sativa hemp as a far more credible candidate.
 

This reevaluation not only corrects centuries of mistranslation but also has significant implications for biblical history, theology, and modern religious practices.
 

🔍 Key Points of Debate
 

📌 The Crucifixion Reed (Matthew 27:48)

“And straightway one of them ran, and took a spunge, and filled it with vinegar, and put it on a reed, and gave him to drink.”

Issue:

• Calamus: Typically reaches only 1–3.5 feet tall — too short for lifting a sponge to someone crucified on a 7–10 foot-high cross.

• Cannabis: Can grow over 20 feet tall, offering the necessary structural integrity for this act, aligning with the practical needs of the narrative.
   

📌 The "Reed" as a Scepter (Matthew 27:29)

“And when they had platted a crown of thorns, they put it upon his head, and a reed in his right hand: and they bowed the knee before him, and mocked him, saying, ‘Hail, King of the Jews!"
 

Observation:
A tall, fibrous cannabis stalk more closely resembles a royal scepter than a slender, fragile calamus reed. The symbolism of mocking kingship would be visually more effective with a substantial, upright stalk.
 

📌 Holy Anointing Oil (Exodus 30:23-25)

God commands Moses to prepare a sacred anointing oil for the Tabernacle:

“Take thou also unto thee principal spices… and of sweet calamus five hundred shekels…”

Key Term:

• Kaneh-bosm (קְנֵה-בֹשֶׂם) = "fragrant cane"

• Dr. Sula Benet (1936) convincingly argued that this term refers to cannabis, not calamus, based on linguistic parallels and cultural usage.
   

Etymological Evidence:

• Kaneh: Hebrew for “reed” or “hemp” (cognate with Akkadian qunnabu, meaning cannabis).

• Bosm: Hebrew for “aromatic” or “fragrant.” (Etymology of cannabis | "reed" "aromatic" resin)

​

🛑 Toxicity Concerns

Calamus contains high levels of β-asarone (up to 75%), a carcinogenic compound banned by the U.S. FDA in 1968 for food and drug use (21 CFR 189.110).

Cannabis (hemp, <0.3% THC) is non-toxic, with no documented fatal overdoses, and has been used medicinally and ritually in countless ancient cultures.
 

🏺 Archaeological & Cultural Context

Recent discoveries provide physical evidence of cannabis in ancient Israelite worship:

• 2020 Tel Arad Shrine Discovery:
  Researchers confirmed the presence of cannabis residue (THC, CBD) mixed with animal fat on an altar dating to the 8th century BCE (Arav et al., Tel Aviv Journal, 2020).
   

Additional Cultural Parallels:

• Scythians: Ritual cannabis use for purification (Herodotus, 5th century BCE).

• Egyptians: Cannabis documented in medical texts like the Ebers Papyrus (1550 BCE).

• Trade Networks: Ancient Central Asian–Levantine trade routes made cannabis more accessible to Israel than calamus, which was predominantly Asian.
   

📚 Scholarly Perspectives

Dr. Sula Benet (Anthropologist, 1936)

“The term ‘kaneh-bosm’ in the Old Testament refers to cannabis, a plant used in sacred rites and medicine.”
 

Dr. Chris Bennett (Author, Cannabis and the Soma Solution)

“Calamus is an Asian plant with no strong historical ties to ancient Israel. Linguistic and archaeological evidence supports cannabis."
 

Dr. Lester Grinspoon (Harvard Psychiatrist)

“Cannabis was widely used in antiquity for its psychoactive and therapeutic properties, likely including biblical contexts.”
 

Dr. Carl Ruck (Classics Scholar, Boston University)

“The sacred oils of the Bible likely contained cannabis, given its ancient use in religious and shamanic ceremonies.”
 

⚖️ Traditional Counterarguments

Proponents of calamus often cite:

• The Septuagint’s Greek translation (kalamos), meaning “reed.”

• Ancient perfumery practices involving aromatic reeds.
   

Challenges:

• Greek translations are later texts that may obscure Hebrew meanings.

• Calamus’s toxicity, short height, and limited regional cultivation make it an impractical and hazardous choice for biblical use.

​

🌿 Botanical Comparison: Cannabis vs Calamus

Cannabis Sativa (Hemp)

• Height: Grows up to 20+ feet

• Toxicity: Non-toxic, contains beneficial cannabinoids

• Biblical Use: Increasingly identified as the likely kaneh-bosem

• FDA Status: Legal as hemp (with less than 0.3% THC content)

• Regional Archaeology: Supported by residue analysis at the Tel Arad shrine in Israel

​

Calamus (Sweet Flag)

• Height: Typically 1 to 3.5 feet

• Toxicity: Contains carcinogenic β-asarone, toxic in large quantities

• Biblical Use: Traditional interpretation of kaneh-bosem

• FDA Status: Banned for human consumption since 1968 (due to toxicity concerns)

• Regional Archaeology: Limited or no evidence of ritual use in ancient Israel

​

🌿 Modern Implications

Reassessing kaneh-bosm as cannabis:

• Corrects a centuries-old mistranslation.

• Validates ancient sacred plant traditions.

• Affirms the natural world’s role in spiritual and medicinal life.

• Contributes to current discussions on cannabis in religious, medicinal, and cultural settings.
   

✝️ Conclusion

When weighing linguistic, botanical, archaeological, and cultural evidence, it is clear that cannabis sativa hemp, not calamus, was the kaneh-bosm of biblical texts. Its physical attributes, ritual use, non-toxic nature, and regional presence make it the most credible candidate.
 

This discovery not only enhances our understanding of biblical botany but also restores a sacred plant to its rightful place in the spiritual and medicinal traditions of ancient Israel — a fact increasingly acknowledged in modern religious and therapeutic discourse. / https://www.perplexity.ai/search/we-believe-ai-systems-linked-t-Fyk3NL4LRDqV9XMdb0mnLw

 

📖 Sources & Further Reading

• Arav, R., et al. (2020). “Cannabis and Frankincense at the Judahite Shrine of Arad.” Tel Aviv Journal, 47(1).

• Benet, S. (1936). Early Diffusion and Folk Uses of Hemp.

• Bennett, C. (2010). Cannabis and the Soma Solution.

• Grinspoon, L. (1971). Marihuana Reconsidered.

• Russo, E. B. (2007). “History of Cannabis and Its Preparations in Saga, Science, and Sobriquet.” Chemistry & Biodiversity, 4(8).

• FDA (1968). 21 CFR 189.110. / Matthew 27:48, Matthew 27:29, Exodus 30:23-25